Season 1 · Episode 7 · 16 November 2026
Fiorentina 1999: Top of Serie A in Winter, Bankrupt by 2002
That winter, Fiorentina were the best team in Italy. Three and a half years later, they did not exist.
Florence, Sunday 7 February 1999. Fiorentina are top of Serie A and Milan are the visitors. In the 87th minute Gabriel Batistuta goes down and does not get up. Within hours Edmundo, the other star of the attack, is at an airport, bound for the Rio Carnival. So how does the best team in Italy in the winter end up bankrupt?
A city that says it invented football, a film family who ran a club like a movie, Trapattoni's years in purple, and a sum of seventy billion lire that turns up in three different stories. The chapters on Vittorio Cecchi Gori's court cases are told from published reports: they are four separate cases, a charge is not a verdict, and where we found no outcome we say so.
In this story: 23 chapters · about 40 minutes to read
- The 87th minute
- Purple
- Close, and never close enough
- The film family
- The striker from the television
- The year of the debt
- The good years
- The old fox
- The Animal
- A very good autumn
- The night in Salerno
- Winter champions
- 18 seconds
- The flight
- The float
- A leak, not a collapse
- Wembley
- The sale of the lion
- The summer of 2001
- The accounts
- Four different courts
- Florentia Viola
- The answer
1The 87th minute
That winter, Fiorentina were the best team in Italy. Three and a half years later, they did not exist.
Florence. Sunday, 7 February 1999. The Stadio Artemio Franchi is full, and from end to end it is purple. Fiorentina are top of Serie A. Not near the top. On top. And Milan are the visitors today.
Fiorentina have won every one of their ten home games this season. Their centre-forward, Gabriel Batistuta, has scored 17 goals in the first 17 league games. The city has not won a title for 30 years, and this winter people have started saying the word out loud. Scudetto.
The match itself is nervous and dull. Around the 80th minute Batistuta and the Milan striker Oliver Bierhoff go up for a ball together, and Batistuta takes a knock. He plays on. Seven minutes later, in the 87th, a long ball comes over from Pasquale Padalino. Batistuta goes down. And this time he does not get up.
Sky Sport, telling the story years later, says he asked to go back on, and was not allowed. He is carried off on a stretcher. The Franchi goes quiet in a way that a stadium rarely does. It finishes 0-0, and nobody remembers the last three minutes.
There is another man in a purple shirt that afternoon whose mind is somewhere else. Edmundo, the Brazilian, the other star of the attack, has a plane to catch. Rio de Janeiro is about to begin its Carnival, and he intends to be there.
Within hours he is at an airport, with reporters in front of him. What he says is quoted for years. I am going to Rio, and I do not know if I am coming back.
That is the whole evening. A knee, and a flight.
Now, hold both of those pictures for a moment, because here is the odd part. The club will be excluded, its debts will be counted in hundreds of billions of lire, and its owner will be the subject of court cases that run for almost 20 years. A new club will start again in the fourth tier, with a different owner and the same colour.
So this is the question for the next hour. How does the best team in Italy in the winter end up bankrupt? Was it that knee? Was it that flight? Or was the answer sitting somewhere else the whole time, in the accounts, long before the ball was kicked?
This is the story of Fiorentina's last great team. A film family who ran a football club like a movie. A striker who cried when he scored against them. And a sum of 70 billion lire that turns up in three different stories, and means something different in each one.
To find out, we are going to leave that Sunday for a while. We start in a city that thinks it invented football.
2Purple
Florence is a small city with a very large opinion of itself. Dante wrote here. Michelangelo carved here. The Medici paid for most of it. People from Florence do not feel they come from the north of Italy, or the south. They feel they come from Florence, and the rest of the country can arrange itself around that.
They also say they invented football. Not exactly, of course. But the claim has a date. On 17 February, fifteen thirty, the city was under siege by the army of the Emperor Charles the Fifth. The Florentines answered by playing a match. In the big square in front of the church of Santa Croce, with musicians on the rooftops and the drums going, in full view of the enemy on the hills. Today the city council still tells the story as a piece of pure defiance.
The game was calcio fiorentino. Two teams, a ball, and almost no rules: part football, part wrestling, part street fight. It was revived in 1930, and every summer it is played again in Santa Croce, by grown men who really do hit each other.
The football club is much younger. Fiorentina were founded in 1926, when small local clubs were merged into one. And they began in the colours of the city, which are red and white.
So why purple? There are two answers. The tidy one is that the club's founder, the Marquis Luigi Ridolfi, saw a Hungarian side, Ujpest, in white and purple in a friendly in 1928, loved the shirts, and imposed the colour the next year. Several club histories give it that way.
The better one, naturally, is the legend: the first red and white shirts were washed in the Arno by a washerwoman, and came out purple. Nobody believes it. Everyone repeats it.
Either way, it stuck. The fans are called the viola, the violets. The club is La Viola. And it is a club that, for most of its life, has been close to greatness and has never quite been allowed to hold it.
Fiorentina won their first league title in 1956 and their second in 1969. Otherwise, for most of a century, they came close. Three times in particular. And each time, something was taken from them. The third time, the thing taken was a boy with a left foot, and the city went to war.
3Close, and never close enough
The first time was 1957. Fiorentina, champions of Italy the year before, reach the final of the European Cup, the second one ever played. And it is staged in Madrid, in Real Madrid's own stadium, the Bernabéu, on 30 May.
It stays 0-0 until the second half. Then a Real Madrid forward, Enrique Mateos, goes down for a foul that looks as if it happened outside the area. The linesman has his flag up for offside. The Dutch referee, Leo Horn, ignores the flag and points to the spot. Alfredo Di Stefano scores. Francisco Gento adds a second. Real Madrid win 2-0, and Florence has an argument that is still going.
The second time was 1982. The last Sunday of the Serie A season, 16 May. Fiorentina and Juventus are level on 44 points. Fiorentina are at Cagliari. Juventus are at Catanzaro. At Cagliari, Francesco Graziani puts the ball in the net, and the referee rules it out for a foul on the goalkeeper. 0-0. At Catanzaro, Juventus are given a penalty for a handball, and Liam Brady scores it. Catanzaro say they should have had one first. Juventus win the title.
The man in charge of Juventus that day was Giovanni Trapattoni. Hold on to that. In Florence, nobody ever forgot it, and that afternoon is where the city's hatred of Juventus is usually said to begin.
The third time was 1990, and it was the worst. Fiorentina reach the UEFA Cup final, and the opponents are Juventus. They lose the first leg 3-1 in Turin on 2 May. The second leg is on the 16th, in Avellino, on neutral ground, after trouble with their own fans earlier in the tournament had cost them their home grounds. It ends 0-0. Juventus win the cup.
And within two days, the news arrives. The club's owner, Flavio Pontello, has sold Roberto Baggio to Juventus.
Baggio is the idol of the city, a 23-year-old with a left foot that bends the rules of physics. The reaction is not a protest. It is a riot. For two days Florence burns: bricks, chains, even petrol bombs, according to the reports. Pontello has to shelter inside the stadium. About 50 people are hurt. Folk memory has Baggio himself leaving the city hidden in the back of a car.
Pontello cannot stay. He needs a buyer, and fast. And the one who turns up is not a football man at all. He is a man who makes movies.
4The film family
His name is Mario Cecchi Gori. Born in Brescia in 1920, he is a film producer, and not a small one. He has put his name on more than 200 movies. One of them, Mediterraneo, wins the Oscar for best foreign film. Another, Il Postino, is nominated for best picture, and wins the Oscar for its music.
In the summer of 1990 he buys Fiorentina. The Florentines, who are hungry for a hero after Baggio, greet him almost as a saviour.
Why would a film producer want a football club? The warm answer, in ESPN's retelling, is that he did it for his wife. Her name was Valeria, she was a lifelong fan, and the two of them had met at a Fiorentina and Juventus match, back in 1938. L'Unita, the Italian paper, wrote years later that nobody ever proved it was Valeria who pushed him. Either way, the love story stuck. Around Florence, they say, when Fiorentina were relegated a few years later, she was found crying on the kitchen floor.
Mario is the president. But the man who actually runs the club from the first day is his son. Vittorio Cecchi Gori, born in Florence in 1942, is the vice-president, and he is a different animal. Louder. Faster. More in love with the spotlight. Vittorio makes films too, with the same company, and over the next years he builds a small empire around them: cinemas, television, and in the mid-nineties a seat in the Italian Senate. His comedy Il ciclone, in 1996, takes about 75 billion lire in the cinemas, a record for its season. It was said around Florence that he even bought an apartment from Donald Trump.
Father and son share one idea about football, and it is the idea at the heart of this story. A club is a film, and the president knows as much about the game as the man picking the team. You find a star, you put him in the shop window, you spend whatever the story needs. And you worry about the bill later.
Hold on to that idea. It is the first piece of the answer to the question we started with.
The first star is about to arrive. And he does not arrive from Italy, or from Brazil, or from anywhere you would expect. He arrives from a television screen.
5The striker from the television
Gabriel Batistuta was born on 1 February 1969, in Reconquista, a town in northern Argentina. He did not even want to be a footballer. He studied. He played basketball. It was football that kept coming back for him, and by his early twenties he had passed through Newell's Old Boys, River Plate and Boca Juniors.
Then, in the summer of 1991, the Copa América is played in Chile, and Batistuta is the top scorer, with six goals. Argentina win it. And that is where Vittorio Cecchi Gori comes in.
How did Vittorio find him? He liked to tell it himself, and the version people repeat is that he spotted the striker playing for his country. A quieter version, reported by Goal, says Vittorio had really been following Boca to look at a playmaker called Diego Latorre, a man meant to replace Baggio, and noticed the other Argentine instead. Both versions end the same way. On 18 August 1991, Batistuta signs. The fee, according to calciomercato, was 5 billion lire. It is one of the best bargains of the decade. Fans swear he even moved into Baggio's old house.
The next summer, Vittorio spends. Brian Laudrup comes, Stefan Effenberg comes, a striker called Francesco Baiano comes. And a new away shirt is made, white with a purple pattern. Halfway through the season, a reader of an Italian newspaper points out something. Look closely at the pattern, he says. It looks like a swastika. The club and the maker, Lotto, say it was an accident, a trick of the repeating design. The shirt is withdrawn. Nobody quite wants to talk about it again.
That is the mood of the season: grand plans, clumsy results.
On 3 January 1993, Fiorentina lose at home to Atalanta. By one account, Vittorio and the coach, Luigi Radice, have a furious argument afterwards about how the team should defend. Radice is sacked. In his place comes Aldo Agroppi, a favourite of old Mario. His first match is a 4-0 defeat at Udinese.
From there it is a slide. Fiorentina finish 16th. They are level on 30 points with Brescia and Udinese, and the head-to-head record sends Florence down.
Ten days before the end of that season, a Mafia car bomb had exploded beside the Uffizi, and killed five people. Football was not the worst thing to happen to Florence that spring. Next to that, relegation was small. But for the club, it was still a funeral. For the first time in more than 50 years, Fiorentina were going to play in Serie B.
Five months later, one of the two men who owned the club was dead.
6The year of the debt
Mario Cecchi Gori died on 5 November 1993, in Rome. He was 73. Near the end, Mario is said to have asked Silvio Berlusconi to look after Vittorio, who was impulsive and naive. Whether he said it or not, from that day the club belonged to Vittorio alone.
And here is the first thing Vittorio did right. He kept the players. Batistuta, who could have left for a bigger club, stayed in Serie B. He scored 16 league goals. The new coach, Claudio Ranieri, won the second division with 50 points, five clear of Bari. A young goalkeeper called Francesco Toldo became first choice. One banner in the stands, it is remembered, said: there is nothing to celebrate, you only paid back a debt.
Then, in the summer of 1994, came the second great signing. Giancarlo Antognoni, the club's old captain, who had nearly died on the pitch in 1981 in a collision with a goalkeeper, and was now a director, brought a Portuguese midfielder from Benfica. Manuel Rui Costa was 22, and he played the game as if the ball were on a string.
Legend has it that Rui Costa had almost joined Barcelona, and that a photograph exists of him in the Barcelona shirt. In Florence, he was loved like a local. The word was that he lived in the old town, walked the museums, read guidebooks. Another story, which nobody has ever proved, says he used to chat on the club's web forum under a made-up name, as a fan. And the best line of all belongs to Vittorio. When Berlusconi, then the owner of Milan, asked the price of Rui Costa, Vittorio is supposed to have answered: some things cannot be bought.
Back in Serie A in 1994 and 95, Fiorentina finish tenth. But Batistuta scores 26 league goals, and he scores in each of the first 11 matches, a new record for the league.
The team has a hero up front, a magician behind him, and a young goalkeeper at the back. The president has a new film coming, and a club that has just got its smile back.
7The good years
1996 is the best year of the Cecchi Gori era, and it begins with a cup. Fiorentina are on their way to finishing third in the league, level on points with Lazio. They also want a trophy. In the Coppa Italia semi-final they meet Inter, and Batistuta scores all four of Fiorentina's goals across the two legs. 4-1 on aggregate.
The final is against Atalanta. On 2 May 1996, at the Franchi, Batistuta scores in the 52nd minute, 1-0. 16 days later at Bergamo, it is 2-0 to Fiorentina, with Amoruso scoring first and Batistuta again. 3-0 on aggregate. The first trophy of the Cecchi Gori years.
Another banner goes up, as fans recall it: for Mario, and for us. And Francesco Flachi, who played alongside Batistuta, remembers that before games, in the tunnel, he used to look at him for reassurance. Just to see that Batistuta was calm. Then he felt calm too.
The summer brings a bigger prize. The Supercoppa, the Italian super cup, is played at San Siro against Milan on 25 August 1996. Fiorentina win 2-1, and Batistuta scores both goals, one of them a long free kick. He runs to the television camera and shouts, for the whole country to hear, a message to his wife. Irina, I love you.
Think about where Fiorentina are at this moment. They have a cup, a super cup, a hero who is a scorer and a romantic, and a president whose comedy is breaking the box office.
But the bill is coming. In the spring of 1997 the club reaches the Cup Winners' Cup semi-final, and loses 3-1 on aggregate to Barcelona. At the home leg, reportedly, coins are thrown, and the Franchi is closed for European matches. Fiorentina will have to play their European home games somewhere else. Ranieri leaves for Valencia. A new coach, Alberto Malesani, finishes fifth, and wins a place in the UEFA Cup. And in the summer of 1998, Vittorio makes his boldest decision.
He wants a title. And he wants to hire the one man in Italy who has won it more than anyone else, who in Florence is also the least popular. He wants Giovanni Trapattoni.
8The old fox
In Florence, nobody has forgotten who was sitting on the Juventus bench on the last day of 1982. Trapattoni won six Serie A titles with Juventus. The European Cup. Everything. To a Florentine, he is the man who took the scudetto from them, and now Vittorio wants to put him in charge of the purple team.
Trapattoni is 59. He has just come from Bayern Munich, and he has left in a way the whole of Germany still remembers. On 10 March 1998, two days after a defeat at Schalke, he walks into a press conference and unloads on his own players. Strunz, Scholl, Basler. Strunz, he says, has been at the club for two years, has played ten games, and is always injured. Some players, he says, are as weak as an empty bottle. For about three and a half minutes he goes on. And then he finishes with a sentence in broken German that every German can quote. Ich habe fertig. I have finished.
It sounds spontaneous. It was not. Years later, in his biography, Trapattoni wrote that he had prepared it carefully.
That is the man Vittorio hires. Trapattoni takes the job on 1 July 1998. At his first training camp in the mountains, a fan shouts at him: old Juventino! The coach, as the Florentines tell it, shouts back: Juventino, yes. Old, no.
He brings new people. A right-back named Moreno Torricelli, who nobody in Italy would have noticed if not for a friendly match. In the summer of 1992, a small team called Caratese, from the fifth division, played Juventus in a friendly. Torricelli was a carpenter by day and a part-time footballer at night. Trapattoni, then at Juventus, noticed him, and within weeks he had signed. He went on to win everything with Juventus. Now he follows his old coach to Florence.
Also arriving are a hard Czech defender called Tomas Repka, a German midfielder, Joerg Heinrich, from Borussia Dortmund, and the Spaniard Guillermo Amor, from Barcelona.
The stars stay. Toldo in goal. Rui Costa behind the strikers; Trapattoni compares him, by repute, to Alfredo Di Stefano. And Batistuta, who comes back from the World Cup in France with five goals. At that tournament, Batistuta says, Trapattoni came to see him, and won him over with one line: the more forests you walk into, the more wolves you meet.
And then there is the one who was already there. The one nobody can quite manage. Edmundo.
9The Animal
Edmundo Alves de Souza Neto was born on 2 April 1971, and everyone in Brazil knows him by his nickname. O Animal. The Animal. It describes how he plays, and it describes how he lives.
He is fast, he is fearless, he is an artist with the ball at his feet. He plays for Vasco da Gama, Flamengo, Corinthians, Palmeiras, and wherever he goes, he scores and he gets sent off. He wins two league titles in a row with Palmeiras, in 1993 and 94, alongside a young left-back called Roberto Carlos.
And he is, to put it kindly, difficult. In the Copa Libertadores in 1995, Palmeiras lose 1-0 to El Nacional in Quito, and Edmundo misses a penalty. Then he loses his temper in front of a television crew. Lance, the Brazilian paper, says a camera ends up smashed on the ground. Edmundo says he tripped on the cables, and that the camera fell on his head. The Ecuadorian union of cameramen does not accept his explanation and files a complaint, and a court orders his arrest.
To keep him out of jail, Palmeiras lock him in a room at the team hotel. For three days, Lance says, the police and the army wait outside. The club's vice-president goes to the Brazilian embassy and negotiates. Eventually, Edmundo is allowed to go home.
In 1997, back at Vasco, he is untouchable: reportedly 29 goals in 28 games, and seven red cards. Vasco win the Brazilian league, Brazil win the Copa América, and Fiorentina buy him. The agreement is reached, calciomercato reports, on 9 July, for about 13 billion lire. He will not play for the club until the new year.
His first Italian winter does not go well. Alberto Malesani, the coach, benches him. When the Carnival arrives in February, 1998, Edmundo simply flies to Rio, clashes with the coach, comes back at the end of March, and is fined by Cecchi Gori. His line, reported by calciomercato, is simple: I prefer to stay in Brazil. His first goal for Fiorentina comes against Napoli in a 4-0 win.
Keep that trip in your head. It is not the one you are thinking of. That one is yet to come.
At the World Cup in France that summer, Edmundo is in the Brazil squad. And, depending on whom you ask, he is the man who saved Ronaldo's life. Edmundo's version, which he has told on a Brazilian podcast, is that he saw Ronaldo having convulsions in the hotel before the final and ran through the corridors shouting for help. Leonardo, Ronaldo's team-mate, has told Corriere dello Sport that it was Roberto Carlos who saw it first. Nobody else has confirmed the Edmundo version.
What nobody disputes is that Edmundo was named in the first line-up in Ronaldo's place, before Ronaldo was cleared to play.
Back in Italy that summer, by one account, Edmundo sat down with Trapattoni and asked for the same wage as Batistuta and Rui Costa. And got a second upgrade to his contract.
And then there is the chimp. Goal's German edition says that for his son's birthday, Edmundo hired a whole circus, and ended up getting the chimpanzee drunk on whisky and beer. That is the man Trapattoni has to manage.
Remember where this is going. In three and a half years, this club will not exist. Nothing in this dressing room explains that yet.
10A very good autumn
The season begins on 12 September 1998, and the first thing it brings is a 2-0 win over Empoli. A week later, Vicenza, 2-1 away. And on the 26th, the big one. At San Siro, Fiorentina play Milan, the future champions, and Batistuta scores a hat-trick. Milan one, Fiorentina three.
That autumn, Batistuta also starts to celebrate with an imaginary machine gun. The masseur, Luciano Dati, tells the story. Dati wears number zero zero seven on his Fiorentina shirt, and the seven is shaped like a pistol. One day he shows it to Batistuta after the warm-up and says: when you score, shoot me. Batistuta scores, aims, and fires, and Dati falls to the grass.
The next day there is criticism, because of the war in Bosnia. So Batistuta keeps the machine gun. But he stops shooting people.
Dati has another claim, and he swears by it. Batistuta, he says, played in boots a size and a half too small, because he liked the feel of the ball, and because he wanted to burst them with the shot. He wore a 41 and a half, where his feet wanted a 43. And on the thigh of his kicking leg, Dati says, grew an extra muscle that the staff nicknamed the little bomber.
On 4 October, nobody is shooting anyone. Udinese come to the Franchi, and it is 0-0 in the last minute. Then Edmundo picks up the ball near the halfway line, swaps passes with Rui Costa, and drives a shot under the crossbar. 90-second minute, 1-0! Vittorio Cecchi Gori is so moved that he climbs onto the barrier in the stands and applauds. Fiorentina are top.
As Trapattoni tells the story, the Brazilian cries in the dressing room afterwards. He wants respect, he says, and a better contract, because he has a new baby. And the coach, who has a rule never to visit his players at home, drives to Edmundo's house to see the child. That, at least, is the version he tells.
It does not last. On 17 October, Roma away. Fiorentina lead, and Trapattoni takes off Edmundo, perhaps with one eye on the next game. Edmundo walks to the bench and tells his coach what he thinks of him, in a mixture of Italian and Portuguese, in front of the cameras. Roma score twice late on, and win 2-1. Dati, who was sitting next to Trapattoni, remembers that after the match the coach apologised to the player.
Then comes a 4-0 win over Salernitana at the Franchi, on the 25th. And on the 31st, a 2-0 defeat at Parma.
Seven rounds are played. Juventus are top with 16 points, Fiorentina second with 15. It is a title race with all the usual pieces, and a clash of egos at its centre. But the next test is not in the league. It is on a Tuesday night in the south of Italy, in a stadium that Fiorentina were not supposed to be in at all.
11The night in Salerno
Let us do this properly, step by step, because it is one of the strangest nights in the club's history.
Step one. Fiorentina are in the UEFA Cup, in the second round, against Grasshopper of Zurich. But their own ground, the Franchi, is closed for European games, reportedly after coins were thrown at the Barcelona match the year before. So the home leg is moved to the Arechi stadium, in Salerno.
Step two. On 20 October, in Zurich, Fiorentina win 2-0. Batistuta scores in the 20th minute, Anselmo Robbiati early in the second half.
Step three. On the 25th, Salernitana, the home team in Salerno, play at the Franchi in the league and lose 4-0. Italian accounts say the supporters of the two clubs clashed in Florence, and that there was a score to settle.
Step four. 3 November, a Tuesday. About 40,000 people are in the Arechi. Luis Oliveira scores in the 12th minute, 1-0. Grasshopper equalise. In the 38th minute, Oliveira scores again. 2-1 to Fiorentina at half-time. 4-1 on aggregate.
Step five. At the interval, something is thrown from the stands. A firecracker! It explodes next to the match officials, and hits the fourth official, who is carried away, one account says, on a stretcher. One football-history writer says he was a Belgian, hurt in the knee. Most sources say fourth official; English Wikipedia says a linesman. The referee abandons the match.
Step six. Four days later, on 7 November, UEFA's disciplinary committee meets. It awards Grasshopper a 3-0 win, which makes it 3-2 on aggregate, and expels Fiorentina from the tournament. A heavier ban was considered, and dropped. The committee noted mitigating factors: the match was played far from Florence, and there was credible evidence that the thrower was a supporter of the local club.
That detail matters. In the popular version, the Salernitana fans did it to get their own back. Nobody has been named in anything we found. It is a story, not a verdict.
One last piece of colour. Gli eroi del calcio, an Italian football history site, says Cecchi Gori had planned to give the whole gate of that match to the victims of the disaster at Sarno, earlier that year. If so, a charity night ended with Fiorentina thrown out of Europe.
Fiorentina have no European football left. But they have a league to win.
12Winter champions
And in the league, Fiorentina go back to winning. 8 November, Venezia, 4-1, and they are top again with 18 points. They lose at Piacenza on the 15th, but beat Inter on the 22nd. Then Bari, Bologna. And then 13 December, the feast of Saint Lucy.
The Franchi is packed for Juventus. In the second half, Luis Oliveira crosses from the right and Batistuta heads it in past Peruzzi. 1-0. A Juventus player, Montero, is sent off for a second yellow card.
Now look at the table, because this is the best Fiorentina will ever look. After 13 rounds they are four points clear of Milan, seven clear of Inter, and ten clear of Juventus.
By January it is closer. They lose 2-0 at Lazio on the tenth, and, reportedly, Rui Costa is furious with Edmundo and wants him taken off. Parma draw level with them on 32.
Then comes the 17th. Fiorentina beat Cagliari, 4-2, in the last game of the first half of the season, and Batistuta scores again. By the end of that round, they are the winter champions, three points clear of Parma and Lazio.
That night, as Vittorio Cecchi Gori tells it, he invites three people to dinner at his villa: Batistuta, Rui Costa, and Antognoni. He proposes what he calls the pact for the scudetto. The three of them will look after Edmundo. In return, he will make them the future of the club. Batistuta will be president someday. Rui Costa will be general manager.
On the television in the corner, as they eat, there is a replay of the goal of the day. At Parma, Lazio's Roberto Mancini has just scored with the back of his heel, from a corner. Lazio win 3-1, and the title race is suddenly crowded.
Look at what that evening describes. A club in January, at the top, with the best attack in Italy, trying to build a bridge between three men and a fourth who cannot be managed.
Fiorentina win at Empoli 3-0, and at home to Vicenza 3-0, their tenth win in ten at the Franchi. By the end of January they are three points clear of Lazio, and five clear of Milan.
Next up are Milan, the following Sunday, 7 February. The match we started with.
1318 seconds
In the week of the Milan match, Edmundo goes to see Trapattoni. He has a clause in his contract, he says, that lets him fly to Rio de Janeiro for Carnival. He intends to use it. Sky Sport reports the clause as a fact. Planet Football calls it an apparent one. The contract itself has never been shown in public, as far as we could find.
Trapattoni, as he has told it, is not happy, but he does the sums. Fiorentina lead Lazio by three points and Milan by five. They are unbeaten at home. If they beat Milan with Edmundo on the pitch, that lead will cover the trip. It is the logic of a man who has never been to Rio at Carnival time.
Sunday, 7 February. Milan at the Franchi. And Edmundo does what Edmundo does. He gets the ball, and he holds it. He holds it against seven Milan players. 18 seconds, by one count; 20, by another. He keeps it from his own team-mates. Then he loses it. Batistuta, by one version, demands that the coach take him off.
The match tightens. Around the 80th minute, Batistuta and Bierhoff jump together for a corner, and Batistuta takes a knock. He needs treatment. He gets up, and plays on.
In the 87th minute, the Milan half is wide open. Padalino sends a long ball. Batistuta runs for it, and goes down, clutching the knee. The stadium falls silent. Sky says he asked to go back on, and was refused.
Trapattoni is standing on the touchline. In his telling, he turns to Edmundo, who is sitting on the bench, and says: no carnival. Edmundo goes white.
It finishes 0-0. The point leaves Fiorentina on 42. Lazio, who won that day, are just behind, on 41. Milan, under Alberto Zaccheroni, with 37, are five points back, and will go on to win the title.
Afterwards, Sky Sport reports, Trapattoni says that he would rather have lost the match than lose Batistuta.
It is a nice sentence. It is also useless.
14The flight
The hours after the match are told in pieces, and the pieces do not agree. So here is the account that is attributed to Trapattoni's own book, and then the others.
In his version, as it has been retold, Edmundo showers quickly after the final whistle and leaves the ground before the coach has done his television interview. Trapattoni, seeing that, jumps into a car and drives to the airport at Pisa. He finds Edmundo in the terminal. And the coach, a man of 59, who has won the league six times with Juventus, goes down on his knees. Edmundo walks on through security.
We could not check that against the book itself, so treat it as the coach's version.
The other account is easier to picture. At Malpensa, Milan's big airport, the reporters catch up with him. Edmundo is in a hurry. And he says the sentence that follows him for the rest of his career. I am going to Rio, and I do not know if I am coming back. He is also quoted as saying that after the season he would not come back, even if Fiorentina showered him with gold, the way they did Batistuta.
By Monday, the club's story shifts. First, the director, Luciano Luna, is reported to deny that there is any carnival clause. Then he accepts that there is one, tied to Edmundo's court appearances in Brazil. And Vittorio Cecchi Gori is said to tell reporters that he gave permission himself, for ten free days.
Meanwhile, the knee. 48 hours after the match, Batistuta appears at a press conference on crutches. Sky reports the diagnosis as a sprained knee, about 40 days out. The masseur, Luciano Dati, says he spent the night with Batistuta, and that it was not the cruciate ligament, as they had feared, but a small piece of tendon beside the knee. In Dati's account, it took about 50 days.
Batistuta is in no mood to forgive. At that press conference, as reported, he calls the club weak and hypocritical, for saying Edmundo had gone for personal reasons. The captain is publicly attacking his own president.
21 years later, in a documentary called El Numero Nueve, Batistuta still has not changed his mind. Gazzetta dello Sport, reporting the film in 2020, quotes him. He calls Edmundo's escape a betrayal, and says it was the beginning of the end of his story with Fiorentina.
In the stadiums of Italy, a chant is heard. It rhymes. Batistuta all'ospedale, Edmundo e carnevale. Batistuta in the hospital, Edmundo at the Carnival.
Edmundo, meanwhile, is in Rio.
So was this it? A knee and a flight, and the end of a club? Not yet. Fiorentina are still top of the table. The question is what happens next.
15The float
Edmundo spends the next days where he has always wanted to be. He plays footvolley on the beach with the old Brazilian star Renato Gaucho. He parades in the Sambodromo with the Salgueiro samba school. And, in one account, he kisses a Vasco da Gama shirt on the float, for the cameras, with the whole of Italy watching.
The reaction in Italy is savage. The journalist Giorgio Tosatti calls it the most selfish act he has seen in 40 years. Trapattoni, according to Planet Football, tells his player to grow up. And the Italian papers report a row. Edmundo, they say, called Batistuta a loser. Rui Costa answered that Batistuta was fighting while Edmundo was partying. Whether those were the exact words, nobody outside the dressing room can say.
On the pitch, the team goes on without both of them. 14 February, at Udinese. Fiorentina lose, 1-0. Sky Sport says this is the moment they lost first place for good.
Let us follow the table. After that defeat, Lazio have caught them. A week later Fiorentina draw 0-0 with Roma, with Edmundo back in the team, and Lazio are two points clear. The week after that, 1-1 at Salernitana.
A two-point gap. On the pitch, nothing. In the head, everything. The Brazilian is back, though one English-language page says he returned two days late, citing Corriere della Sera, and we found no second source for that. Either way, Italy has stopped treating him as a footballer and started treating him as a problem.
The Coppa Italia still offers a way out. In the semi-final, Fiorentina win the first leg at Bologna, 2-0, and then, at home, are two goals down after 90 minutes. In extra time, as Fiorentina fans tell it, Tomas Repka scores, and in the 100 and 18th minute Rui Costa wins it from the penalty spot. They will meet Parma in the final. And Parma's coach is the man who left Fiorentina for them the summer before: Alberto Malesani.
16A leak, not a collapse
The spring of 1999 is not a collapse. It is a leak.
Fiorentina beat Parma on 7 March. Then they lose 4-1 at Venezia. They beat Piacenza, in a game where Edmundo is recalled and substituted yet again, and throws, they say, another tantrum; Carmine Esposito scores the winner in stoppage time. Then a defeat by Inter, a draw at Bari, a 3-0 defeat by Bologna, and a defeat by Juventus. After 30 rounds they are eight points behind Lazio.
Vittorio Cecchi Gori is busy that spring. On 21 March, La vita e bella, a film that his group helped to make, wins three Oscars. As a producer he is at the top of the world. As a club president, in the same weeks, he tries an anti-crisis plan, in one description: dinners for the players, silence for the press, and fewer training sessions. And Edmundo, it is said, is promised a release after the cup final.
The final is played over two legs against Parma. The first leg, in April, ends 1-1: Hernan Crespo for Parma, Batistuta for Fiorentina. The second is on 5 May at the Franchi. Fiorentina come from behind to lead 2-1. And then, in the 71st minute, a Parma left-back, Paolo Vanoli, makes it 2-2. Parma win on away goals.
A week later, Malesani wins the UEFA Cup with Parma in Moscow, and Vanoli scores in that final too. Remember Vanoli.
Between the two legs, on 2 May, Fiorentina had thrashed Perugia 5-1. On the ninth they lose at Sampdoria. And on 15 May they hold Lazio to 1-1 at the Franchi, which hands the lead of the league to Milan with one round to go. On the last day Lazio beat Parma and Milan won at Perugia, and Milan win the title by a point, 70 to Lazio's 69. Fiorentina finish third with 56, a point ahead of Parma.
From the Milan draw to the end of the season, 15 league games: three wins, six draws, six defeats. 15 points. That is what a leak looks like.
Third place sends Fiorentina into the Champions League qualifiers. And Edmundo goes back to Vasco da Gama. The fee, depending on the source, is 23 billion lire, or about 15 million dollars. Fiorentina have lost the second of their two stars. And Europe's biggest stage is waiting.
17Wembley
Summer, 1999. Edmundo is gone, and Vittorio has money to spend. Enrico Chiesa arrives from Parma, for about 14 million euros, according to Wikipedia. Predrag Mijatovic comes from Real Madrid. Abel Balbo, the Argentine, joins. Fiorentina beat Widzew Lodz 5-1 on aggregate in the qualifiers, and for the first time in the Champions League era, they are in the group stage.
The start goes wrong. 0-0 at home to Arsenal. A 4-2 defeat at Barcelona. By late October, Fiorentina have lost three league games in a row, and a week before the biggest night of the year, Goal reports, Trapattoni offers to resign. Cecchi Gori refuses.
27 October. Old Wembley, with the twin towers. Arsenal have been using it for their European home games, because Highbury is too small, a choice that Arsene Wenger will later call a mistake. More than 70,000 people are in the ground.
It is 0-0 with 15 minutes left. Then, in the 75th minute, Batistuta takes the ball wide on the right. The angle is almost impossible. He shoots anyway, and the ball flies into the far top corner. 1-0. 11 minutes later, Toldo saves a shot from Nwankwo Kanu, and that is how it ends: Arsenal nil, Fiorentina one.
Batistuta has said that of all his goals in Florence, this is the one that ties him most to the fans.
A week later, a 3-3 draw at the Franchi with Barcelona, Balbo scoring twice, takes Fiorentina through as the second team in the group, with nine points, a point ahead of Arsenal.
In the second group stage they meet Manchester United, the champions of Europe. On 23 November, at the Franchi, Batistuta scores early in the first half, after a loose pass from Roy Keane. Balbo adds a second in the 52nd minute. 2-0. Alex Ferguson blames his defenders.
Then it slips. 0-0 at Bordeaux. A 1-0 home win against Valencia, with a Mijatovic penalty, then a 2-0 defeat in Spain, and a 3-1 defeat at Old Trafford. On 21 March they need to beat Bordeaux in Florence. Bordeaux score in the fifth minute. Fiorentina turn it round, Chiesa from the penalty spot, Batistuta, Rui Costa. And then Bordeaux score in the 87th minute, and again, from a penalty, in the 90th. 3-3. Eight points, third in the group. United are top.
Fiorentina finish seventh in Serie A with 51 points, Batistuta scoring 23 league goals. In the summer Trapattoni's contract runs out and is not renewed. The man who was supposed to bring Florence its title has brought it a night at Wembley, and not much else.
The best player is next to go.
18The sale of the lion
In the summer of 2000, Gabriel Batistuta is 31. He has given nine years to the club. He is the idol of a generation, and he has never won a league title. Roma, the club of the capital, want him, and Fiorentina agree. The fee is 70 billion lire, about 36 million euros as later sources count it.
The new coach is a Turk, Fatih Terim, and the team drifts through the season in the middle of the table. On 26 November 2000, Roma play Fiorentina. The match is heading for a draw when, seven minutes from the end, Batistuta, in a Roma shirt, hits a right-footed volley over Toldo. It is the winner. And he cannot celebrate. He cries. According to calciomercato, Francesco Totti, the Roma captain, lifts him up and carries him back to the centre circle.
That season Roma win the league, with Batistuta scoring 20 league goals. For Roma, a perfect ending.
For Florence, the story gets worse. In February 2001, Terim leaves for Milan. Roberto Mancini, who has only just stopped playing, takes his place. And the club still reaches the Coppa Italia final, against Parma. On 24 May, away, Fiorentina win 1-0 with a goal in the 87th minute. The scorer is Paolo Vanoli, the same Vanoli who scored against them two years earlier, and who is now in the purple shirt. On 13 June, at the Franchi, it ends 1-1. 2-1 on aggregate.
It is Fiorentina's sixth Coppa Italia, and the last trophy the old club ever wins.
Two weeks later, on 27 June, a bankruptcy inquiry opens at the court in Florence, 90 Min reports. The club's debts, the same site says, run to more than 300 billion lire.
Now look at that number, 70 billion. It turns up in three different stories. It is the price of Batistuta. It is, according to the newspaper Unita in 2002, a sum that was moved from the club to Cecchi Gori's finance company, Finmavi, in the 1998/99 season. And it is, according to a Florence civil court in 2019, an advance from a factoring company, against television-rights money, most of it sent on to other companies in the group. Three stories. One round number. They are not the same thing. And this is where the answer to our question starts to show. Not on the pitch. In the accounts.
Batistuta had left before the worst of it, but his body kept a bill of its own. In 2014 he told TyC Sports, an Argentine channel, that after he retired his ankles hurt so much he asked a doctor to cut off his legs. The doctor refused.
19The summer of 2001
The summer of 2001 is when it ends.
Cecchi Gori needs money, and he has a plan. Sell Rui Costa and Toldo, the best two players left, to Parma for 140 billion lire. And both players say no.
Toldo does not want to go. At Parma he would be the man replacing Gianluigi Buffon, who has just left for Juventus, and he does not want to be known as that. Rui Costa also refuses.
So the club sells them elsewhere. Rui Costa goes to Milan for 85 billion lire, a club record for Milan. By the Milan version, the deal is closed at about two in the morning, on 2 or 3 July. The newspaper Unita says the price was really 60 billion lire plus a player. Toldo goes to Inter for 55 billion, announced on the fifth.
On paper, Wikipedia says, the club shows a profit for the season. In real life, it has lost its playmaker and its goalkeeper. A Florence civil judgment in 2019, quoted by Calcio e Finanza, says the sales were used to settle about 180 billion lire of other debt, through credits assigned by the league. Even after a capital increase, a debt of 20 billion lire was left. That debt, the judges said, is why the club was later not allowed to register.
In July, Vittorio Cecchi Gori steps down as president and puts the club up for sale. The date is the ninth, according to 90 Min, and the 30th, according to Italian Wikipedia.
The season opens on 19 August with the Supercoppa, against Roma, the champions, Batistuta's new team. Fiorentina lose 3-0. A week later they lose to Chievo. Chiesa, the main striker, tears a cruciate ligament in the fifth league game. Mancini goes in January. Several more coaches come and go, and Ottavio Bianchi is named club president in April.
In the winter, a teenage Brazilian striker arrives on loan from Inter. His name is Adriano. He scores six league goals.
Fiorentina finish 17th with 22 points: five wins, seven draws, 22 defeats. They go out of the UEFA Cup to Lille in the third round, and they are relegated at the end of April. And the real trouble has not even begun.
20The accounts
On 18 April 2002, 90 Min reports, Vittorio Cecchi Gori is indicted for false accounting and misappropriation. A charge is not a verdict. We will come to the verdicts. About 35,000 fans march through Florence demanding that he sell.
12 days later, Covisoc, the body that checks the finances of Italian clubs, rejects the club's accounts. Without its approval, no club can register for the league.
The rest is a countdown. In late July, Covisoc says that about 22 million euros have to be found by the 29th, to register for Serie B. Cecchi Gori asks for more time. According to 90 Min, he points to a transfer of money from Colombia. It turns out to come from a bank that had failed years before.
The 29th passes. And the old Fiorentina, 76 years old, is out.
Be precise about the date, because the sources are not. 1 August is when the Federal Council in Rome refuses to register the club. La Nazione and 90 Min put the bankruptcy that same day. Quotidiano.net says the court declared bankruptcy later, on 27 September. So here is the safe sentence. On 1 August 2002, the old Fiorentina was excluded, and ceased to exist.
The debts, La Nazione says, are more than 300 billion lire.
In late October, Cecchi Gori is placed under house arrest in the Florence investigation. Unita, on the 30th, says the prosecutors are looking at that transfer of 70 billion lire to Finmavi. An arrest in an investigation is a step. It is not a conviction.
So what did the courts conclude? Not one thing, but four. They are four separate cases, in four separate courts, and it matters to keep them apart.
21Four different courts
Everything in this chapter comes from published reports, and where we found only one source, we say who it is. The first is the bankruptcy of Fiorentina. The criminal case ended with a final conviction of three years and four months, Quotidiano.net reports. Three of those years were covered by the pardon law of 2006, and the Florence appeal court applied the pardon in December 2008, says Il Sole Ventiquattro Ore. Years later, on 16 October 2020, the Rome appeal court revoked it, because of a later conviction. The Court of Cassation rejected his appeal against that in April 2021, Calcio e Finanza reports.
The second is Safin, a film company that went bankrupt, with debts of about 24 million euros. Cecchi Gori was arrested in Rome on 3 June 2008. The first-instance sentence was six years. The Rome appeal court cut it to five years and six months, in October 2018. And in February 2020, the Court of Cassation confirmed it.
The third is Finmavi, the family finance company, which failed in 2006, with liabilities of about 600 million euros, according to the Italian press. Cecchi Gori was arrested on 25 July 2011. In October 2013, a court in Rome sentenced him to seven years for fraudulent bankruptcy. Prosecutors had asked for ten. We could not find what happened on appeal.
The fourth is not criminal at all. In 2019, the civil court in Florence ordered him to pay more than 19 million euros to the trustee of the old Fiorentina, calling him the only person responsible. Several former directors were cleared. His lawyer announced an appeal. We found no outcome.
On 28 February 2020, carabinieri served a prison order that added several sentences together: eight years, five months and 26 days. He later served it under house arrest.
Here is what the record does show. A man who loved the club. A club that collapsed. And criminal courts that convicted him in connection with that collapse, in the Safin bankruptcy, and, at first instance, in the Finmavi case. Where exactly the money went is what four courts have spent almost 20 years trying to untangle.
22Florentia Viola
And then, on 1 August 2002, the city did what Florence always does when it is insulted. It rebuilt.
Diego Della Valle, the head of the shoe company Tod's, steps in, together with the mayor, Leonardo Domenici. According to Italian Wikipedia, on that very day they create a new club, Fiorentina Nineteen Twenty-Six Florentia, soon renamed Florentia Viola. It cannot use the old name. It starts in Serie C-two, the fourth tier of Italian football. And it plays at the Franchi. A photograph of the scoreboard on 13 October 2002 shows Florentia Viola against Rimini: a new club in the old stadium.
Almost nobody is left. Of the senior players, only one stays, Angelo Di Livio, 36 years old. UEFA's website says so.
The little club wins its Serie C-two group in its very first season. Christian Riganò scores 30 league goals, Italian Wikipedia says. And a legal knot, the so-called Catania case, which changed the shape of the leagues, means Florentia Viola do not go up to C-one. They go straight to Serie B.
On 19 May 2003, the club gets back its old name. It is Fiorentina again.
The next season, they finish sixth in Serie B, enough for a promotion play-off against Perugia. On 16 June 2004, they win away, 1-0, with a goal from Fantini. On the 20th, at the Franchi, in front of more than 30,000 people, Fantini scores again in the 47th minute, and is sent off ten minutes later. Perugia equalise late. It finishes 1-1. 2-1 on aggregate.
And somewhere in the crowd that night, UEFA reports, is a man in ordinary clothes. Gabriel Batistuta.
Fiorentina are back in Serie A. Two years after the end, the city has brought back its team, its name and its colour. It is not the same club. But it is the same city. And now we can go back to where we started.
23The answer
The 87th minute. 7 February 1999. A long ball, a knee, a stretcher.
We asked: how does the best team in Italy in the winter end up bankrupt?
Honestly, it was not the knee. A sprained knee costs you six or seven weeks, not a club. It was not the flight either. Edmundo's Carnival cost Fiorentina a mood, and the captain's trust, and some points. Whether it cost them the title, nobody can prove. What the table does show is this. In the 15 league games from that Milan draw, Fiorentina took 15 points. Lazio took 31. Milan took 34.
The real answer was in the accounts. A family of film people bought a football club as if it were a film. You find a star, you put him in the shop window, you pay for the whole production, and you worry about the bill later. For a while, it worked. There was a Coppa Italia, a Supercoppa, Batistuta, Rui Costa, a night at Wembley. Then the bill came in, and by 2002 it was more than 300 billion lire. The team that led Italy in the winter of 99 was paid for with money the club did not have.
Whether that was crime, or mistake, or just a family business that grew bigger than its bank, is something the courts have spent 20 years deciding, in four different rooms. We have told you what they found. We have not decided it for you.
Everyone else, in the end, got something. Batistuta won his league title with Roma. Rui Costa won the Champions League with Milan, in 2003. Toldo won the league with Inter. The only people who had to wait for anything back were the people of Florence.
There is no neat moral. There is only a Sunday in February, a stadium in purple, and a man being carried off on a stretcher while a city held its breath. Three and a half years later, the club was gone.
Enjoyed the story? The film has the pictures, the music and the goals.
Watch Episode 7 on YouTube